Support Us Button Widget

Answered: A BOStoday Hallmark movie

We asked, you answered and your responses have helped us craft the perfect Hallmark movie based in Boston.

christmas tree in quincy market, boston

The holiday filming locations across our city are endless.

Photo via @amyhoro

Table of Contents

We know plenty of movies have been filmed across Boston — there have even been a few holiday flicks filmed here, like “Spirited” starring Ryan Reynolds and Will Ferrell + the 2005 film “Christmas In Boston.” But what if we crafted our own local Hallmark story?

Thanks to your title recommendations, location ideas, plot points, and even which actors you picked for our film, we have mapped out a new Hallmark film in Boston. Here are just a few of the responses to our six-question survey.

Allow us to set the scene.

What’s the title of the movie?

  • “Believe in Beantown” — Helen M.
  • “A Kiss at Frog Pond” — Lizzie G.
  • “Love, Lobster and Pasta” — Mary C.
  • “Snowflakes in Southie” — Emma H.
  • “Relation-shipping up to Boston” — Mary M.
inside of winter market with christmas trees

Shopping local vendors at the SoWa Winter Festival is the perfect place for a potential meet-cute.

Photo by BOStoday team

Where does the meet-cute happen

  • “Run into each other getting coffee and then later meet again cheering on opposite teams at a bar.” — Kaia A.
  • “The snow is falling, the Common’s tree is lit, ice skaters are gliding on Frog Pond. When the dog she’s walking gets loose and slides across the rink, it trips up a first-time skater. As she rushes to help him up and grab her dog, the two become tangled in the leash, and a kiss catches them both by complete surprise.” — Lizzie G.
  • “Arguing over a freshly shoveled parking space.” — Derek S.
  • “Getting on the T at North Station.” — Holly H.
  • “Sowa Market” — Angela M.

What are the major plot points?

  • “Dad’s local business is being shutdown by the boyfriend’s big name company he works for.” — Courtney F.
  • “Girl is back visiting her parents and he works at Fenway Park.” — Holly H.
  • “She’s from Cambridge, he’s from Southie.” — Mary S.
  • “20-ft snow falls during a blizzard.” — Angela M.
  • “Hitting the Storrow Drive bridge with her moving truck.” — Helen M.
  • “Engagement plan gone wrong and gets “dumped” on the tea party boat.” — Lori A.
Courtyard of Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum

Did you know anyone named Isabella gets into the Gardner Museum for free?

Photo by BOStoday

Scenes around Boston to include

  • “Frog Pond, Boston Common, Boston Public Garden.” — Lizzie G.
  • “Harborwalk, Seaport, North End, or anywhere with water.” — Mary M.
  • “Franklin Park Zoo (lanterns and lights), Boston Common, local restaurants in Dorchester and Mattapan.” — Ketsia L.
  • “In a raucous Irish bar.” — David D.
  • “A date at the Isabella Stewart Gardner [Museum].” — Emma H.

Who’s starring in the movie?

  • Casey Affleck and Paige Turco — Mary C.
  • Chris Evans and Amy Poelher — Anita M.
  • Jonathan Tucker and Julia Jones — Mary S.
  • Ayo Edebiri — Ketsia L.
  • Mindy Kaling — Lizzie G + Helen M.
  • Mark Wahlberg — Derek S.
Exterior shot of "Flat of the Hill" in Beacon Hill

There’s no shortage of unique gift shops and cobblestone streets in Beacon Hill.

Additional details to include

  • “Theme of giving to others in need. What the world needs now.” — Diane G.
  • “Snow, maybe even nor’easter, large loud festive homemade Italian meal with a big Italian family, new-to-Boston person unable to crack a lobster claw.” — Mary C.
  • “Drinking iced coffee no matter the cold and some Boston sports team’s season in the background, maybe Bruins.” — Derek S.
  • “A Townie bar and the wise-cracking grandpa, a la Norm from the TV show ‘Cheers.’” — Mary M.
  • “Scenes in Beacon Hill walking hand-in-hand along the cobblestone, at the Seaport, and along the Charles.” — Lizzie G.
  • “A happy ending of course.” — Lori A.
More from BOStoday
Reach your local community with our help.
Sip on the story of Boston’s favorite coffee chain.
To help make your Logan Airport experience as smooth as possible, we’ve created a guide that covers everything from the four terminals to parking and popular international flights.
Celebrate Small Business Week in Boston with the local folks who make up our economy’s backbone.
Whether you are spending a day or a lifetime in Boston, MA, these are some of the best free things to do in town — from outdoor adventures to kid-friendly offerings and beyond.
Multiple online surveys ranked Boston + Massachusetts as places where large scale eco-friendly efforts are making a major impact on protecting the environment.
Lunch near Boston shouldn’t break the bank. From downtown Boston to Cambridge, we’ve got the best lunch spots that everyone can agree on.
Celebrate Small Business Week in Boston with the local folks who make up our economy’s backbone.
BOS-Underground-Ink-Block
13 murals around Boston
Take an artsy adventure around the city to locate these murals.