Support Us Button Widget

Where to buy holiday pies and desserts in Boston

Whether you’re short on time or need to impress the in-laws, our com-pie-lation of local bakeries will help you find the perfect sweet treat.

A slice of pumpkin pie on a white plate with a spoon, atop a green, pink, and white plaid tablecloth. White pumpkins and a full pumpkin pie are also on the table.

Somerville’s Petsi Pies are available at delis and markets in Cambridge, Brookline, Dorchester, and Jamaica Plain.

Photo by @petsipies

You’re gonna need a bigger dinner table. When it comes to holiday dinners, only the upper crust of desserts will do. As you plan your final course, consult this com-pie-lation of local shops baking seasonal sweets.

Capo, 443 W. Broadway | Order deadline: Thursday, Dec. 21
The South Boston restaurant’s lemon meringue, apple blueberry crumble, banoffee (read: banana, toffee + whipped cream), and turtle chocolate pies can be made gluten-free. Don’t overlook their cornucopia of dessert options, like the peanut butter Oreo cheesecake, cake pop bouquets, and cinnamon crunch banana bread.

Fornax Bread Company, 27 Corinth St.
Find chocolate, banana, and Boston cream pies at this Roslindale bakery, plus apple, mixed berry, and blueberry varieties. Short on time? Order one of the meat pies or savory tarts filled with chicken, spinach, or sweet potato for dinner.

The Blue Frog Bakery, 3 Green St. | Order deadline: Wednesday, Dec. 20
Once you’ve placed an order for a pecan or double crust apple pie, take home a soft gingerbread cake — complete with a citrus glaze — or a traditional Yule log, frosted with chocolate ganache and meringue mushrooms.

Clear Flour Bread, 178 Thorndike St., Brookline
Try global treats like Apfelstreusel, raspberry linzer torte, iced gingerbread cake, Austrian nut cookies, and plum-filled berliners. Bonus: German Stollen will be available through Christmas Eve.

Hi-Rise Bread Company, 208 Concord Ave., Cambridge
Look for the five-inch tall pies, piled with mountains of apple filling. We dare you to resist the all-butter Stolle de Noël, made with lemon + orange peels, golden raisins, dried Zante currants, almonds, dark Haitian rum, and native wildflower honey.

Petsi Pies, 285 Beacon St., Somerville | Order deadline: Tuesday, Dec. 19
Shake up your holiday with an apple-pear-cranberry pie with walnuts, sweet potato pecan pie, or chocolate bourbon pecan pie. Chocolate lovers can’t miss the Mississippi mud pie, an indulgent blend of Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel, and chocolate cookie crust, completed with — what else? — a chocolate glaze. Even “Good Morning America” is a fan.

More from BOStoday
These city gifts are way better than a Jelly of the Month Club membership.
The biggest step in completing your New Year’s resolution? Show up.
The new museum at 200 State St. — adjacent to Faneuil Hall — is open daily.
To help make your Logan Airport experience as smooth as possible, we’ve created a guide that covers everything from the four terminals to parking and popular international flights.
Prepare for winter weather in Boston with these seasonal temperature and precipitation outlooks.
Beantown is made up of so many wonderful small businesses, here are a few our readers love in honor of Small Business Saturday.
Show Boston some love with 30+ ways to give back.
Including gifts for neighbors, foodies, significant others, homebodies, students, and gifts under $20.
Hit the town and enjoy a drink after work at one of these cheers-worthy local bars. 🍸